Published on:

Inmate failed to prove excessive force by corrections officers. Bookman v. State, # 2016-015-617 (N.Y. Ct. Cl. Oct. 17, 2016)


Inmates are protected from the use of excessive force by various laws and regulations at both the federal and state levels. One significant federal statute is the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution, which prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, including the use of excessive force by correctional officers. This amendment serves as a fundamental safeguard for inmates’ rights and establishes a baseline standard for the treatment of prisoners.

Additionally, many states have enacted laws and regulations specifically addressing the use of force in correctional facilities. For example, in New York, the Correction Law and the New York Codes, Rules, and Regulations (NYCRR) provide guidelines for the use of force by correctional officers. These laws outline the circumstances under which force may be justified, such as self-defense or maintaining order, and emphasize the importance of using only the minimum amount of force necessary to achieve a legitimate objective.

Furthermore, court decisions, such as those interpreting the Eighth Amendment, help to clarify the legal standards surrounding the use of force in prisons and ensure that inmates are afforded adequate protection against abuse.  Bookman v. State is one of those cases.

Background Facts
In July 2011, while at the Great Meadow Correctional Facility, the claimant, an inmate, found himself in a confrontation with correction officers. It began in the facility commissary, where he was instructed to leave by Correction Officer McNally. Despite complying, he faced further instructions to exit. As he waited in the rotunda area, tensions escalated when he requested to speak with a Sergeant, resulting in him being escorted back to his cell. During this escort, he alleges he was kicked and punched by the officers, sustaining injuries including a black eye and bleeding nose.

The following day, the claimant sought medical assistance and reported the assault to his family, leading to an examination at the facility’s infirmary. Despite his complaints, the correction officers involved denied any misconduct, asserting they merely escorted him to his cell.

Whether the correction officers employed excessive force during the claimant’s escort back to his cell. This required a thorough examination of witness testimonies and evidence presented during the trial.

After careful consideration of the evidence, the court found that the claimant failed to prove the use of excessive force by the correction officers. Testimonies from correction officers and other personnel stationed in the area contradicted the claimant’s allegations. Additionally, the absence of a witness to corroborate the claimant’s version of events weakened his case. Therefore, the claim was dismissed.

In the discussion, the court highlighted the discrepancy between the claimant’s testimony and that of the defendant’s witnesses, the correction officers. While the claimant described being kicked and punched by the officers, the officers testified that they simply escorted him back to his cell without the use of force. This conflicting testimony made it challenging for the court to determine what actually occurred.

Additionally, the court referenced laws and regulations governing the use of force in correctional facilities. It acknowledged that while force is permissible in certain situations, such as self-defense or maintaining order, it must be used judiciously and in accordance with established guidelines.

By examining the evidence presented and assessing the credibility of the witnesses, the court ultimately concluded that the claimant had not proven his case of excessive force. Despite the seriousness of the allegations, the evidence did not sufficiently support the claimant’s claims, leading to the dismissal of the case.

If you feel your rights have been violated while incarcerated in New York, it’s important to take action. One important step is to contact an experienced New York prisoners’ rights lawyer who can provide legal guidance and representation. The proper legal representation can help you understand your legal options, file complaints or lawsuits if necessary, and work to hold responsible parties accountable for any violations. Seeking legal assistance is essential for protecting your rights and seeking justice for any wrongdoing.

Posted in:
Published on:

Comments are closed.

Contact Information